Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Caleb Foster's avatar

David, I consider Paul Gregutt our finest taster in WA because of his not only focused #wawine experience but also because of his lived experience in #Wawine country. When other critics living on the east coast or Europe would come through once a year, I knew they didn’t know anything about our weather and therefore the core force of the vintage. Meanwhile Paul & Karen live(d) in our wine country and even when he was in Seattle he came to wine country. a new critic Owen Bargreen also knows our land well as a Whitman College alumnus. His work can compliment and support Paul’s. Still, Paul has what no one else can imitate: direct experience tasting #wawine upon release in the 80s and following not only those bottles’ lives but also the metamorphosis of the winemaking style of those very same founding wineries. Only Paul can speak authoritatively to the wonderful house style of Leonetti or L’Ecole #41 or Woodward Canyon because of those personal experiences with both the wines, people, vineyards and the lived-in weather of 40 vintages. As a winemaker this is where trust comes in for me.

There are right and wrong criticisms.

For me, Paul is always right, because he truly knows the craft needed to not only produce the vintage new wines but also where it’s laying in #wawine history. I may not agree with him because for example, I don’t like how weird the Cayuse wines have become- for me… but his scores I always respect as accurate. If I could, I’d buy his whole list of 100 great Wa wines and know I’m experiencing the most meaningful wines of the vintage- maybe not the best or even my favorite - but certainly most meaningful.

And Paul, I certainly hope you’re currently writing that second book on #wawine. The world needs specifically your sequel. Vignerons, viticulturalists, wine shop buyers and boardroom CEOs we all need your lasting remarks on #wawine now and as evolved from then. 🙏

Expand full comment
Avennia's avatar

Thanks for including our Oliane and Aerialist!

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts